top of page
Search

Why Write a Military Memoir?

James Ron
2 hours ago
6 min read

Here’s a fragment of something I’m working on. I wonder what you think.

Why do people write military memoirs? To glorify or castigate themselves and their masters, to honor their victims, or to mine their own experience - and that of those around them - for insights into the human condition? Or, perhaps, to seek validation and sympathy?


More importantly, what can an author say that hasn’t been written a million times before? Stories about military life and its impacts are a dime a dozen. Is there anything new to be said? But even if not, does that matter? Isn’t every story unique?


I’m wrestling with these questions as I write about my time in the Israeli military four decades years ago. I'm trying to make sense of what I did and saw, and to explore whether getting it all out is worth the exposure. Is there a higher moral purpose in writing, or is it just a plea for attention? And what about my children? Do they deserve to have this out there?


Below is an excerpt from something I’m working on.


Importantly, I’ve written no Palestinians or Lebanese into this brief passage. They come later, and in some ways, are the focus of everything. And while the recent Gaza war takes place forty years later, the horror of that tragedy hovers over everything. It's difficult to write about Israel, Palestine, Lebanon, and the Israeli military. People feel strongly, and rightly so. Please note that just because I participated all those years ago, doesn’t mean I approve.

That all comes later, however. The first task I have set for myself is to paint a picture of military training and what it did to the brain of an 18-year-old immigrant who desperately wanted to be accepted, and to excel, in Israel's most central institution.


In a garrison state, the military is king, and the most socially accepted path to acceptance - for an 18-year-old, secular, Jewish male - was through its green portal.


I chose the most innocuous manuscript fragment for this post. Feels less vulnerable, I guess.


JANUARY 9, 1985


My first hours in Israel’s military were eerily solitary.


I woke up early in my parents’ condo in a wealthy part of West Jerusalem, Wolfsohn Towers, and at silently in the family’s beige Citroën as Dad drove us to the “Base for Absorption and Sorting” on the outskirts of Tel Aviv.

Dad knew I was headed to the Unit, but over the past two years, my cousin had trained him not to ask questions.


He'd always been a compulsive talker, my father, but on this trip, he had no words. I don’t know if he was silently proud of what I was about to do, or whether he’d already begun to have the kind of doubts that would drive him from the country 25 years later.

It was clear, however, that he had no idea what I was getting into. His own military service had been as a night clerk in the Maryland National Guard, where he recalled answering phones and fudging readiness reports. “The Israeli military never told us what you and your cousin were training for,” Mom told me decades later. “We just assumed it was for an office job. When your father finally found out, he was furious. He would never have agreed to let either of you go.”

I found that hard to believe. What did he think had caused all those bruises?

When we reached the base, I said a hasty goodbye. Like a child on the first day of school, I feared embarrassment in front of the other kids. No one else was there, however, save for the Unit’s driver, who ushered me through the sentries and guided me from office to office.


When we entered each room, the driver showed the person in charge a piece of paper. They read it and got to work silently. One issued me a green uniform and boots; another, a sleeping bag and a canvas duffel. A third told me to sign papers. Not a single person spoke.


It was creepy.


Later, high school friends who went to one of the regular units said they’d languished for weeks in that massive, soul-crushing installation, sweeping sidewalks and cleaning latrines. My bespoke induction, however, lasted all of two hours, and it was then that I realized this Unit, whatever it was, was so powerful it could bend the entire military to its will.


We drove for an hour east, crossing the Green Line dividing Israel from the West Bank. Today, most Israelis call the area “Samaria,” but back then, we just knew it as “the territories.”


After 30 minutes, we turned onto a narrow, potholed road that seemed to have been last paved in Ottoman times. After a short distance, the truck turned onto a dirt path and drove down a gentle, rocky slope. When the vehicle was hidden from view, the driver stopped and motioned for me to dismount.


It was Wednesday afternoon, and I hadn’t spoken to another human all day.


I looked around: hills, stones, and thorns. No Palestinian villages, no Bedouin encampments, no military bases, no Jewish settlements.


“Koolé,” the driver grunted. The Unit’s basic training camp was Koolé. Four pup tents, two larger tents, a metal shack with showers and a toilet, and one truck.


The reception committee consisted of the driver, who promptly disappeared into one of the larger tents, and Tzachi, a short fellow with no discernible expression. Of all the Unit’s representatives, Tzachi was always the most terrifying. The Psychologist was an intellectual, the Grey-Haired Man, avuncular.


Tzachi was something different. A fighting machine, I guess. The epitome of the kind of Israeli man who scared me.


He motioned me to the supply tent, where a new figure silently handed over a pile of gear: a greenish tactical vest, an M16, eight loaded magazines, and other items I couldn’t identify. I awkwardly began stuffing bits and pieces into the vest’s pouches, couldn’t figure out what went where, and looked to Tzachi for help. All he said was, “Hurry up.” He was not a warm man.


My canteens weren’t properly closed, and I sensed I’d shoved the bandage into the wrong pouch. One of the Velcro flaps covering a magazine pocket wouldn’t stay shut, and I couldn’t figure out how to attach the flashlight. Everything was dripping precariously from the vest, but I didn’t know how to fix it.


Tzachi charged across a field, slipping over sharp boulders while I stumbled behind. Every few steps, I tripped and fell. When my rifle hit the rocks for the third time with a clatter, he finally glanced back.


“Pick up your knees.”


We reached a small clump of silent boys watching another sprint uphill. A tall man, the Commander, followed closely behind. Every few seconds, the running boy dropped to the ground, crawled behind a boulder, and then continued to dash uphill, screaming words I couldn’t hear. When he reached the crest, he spoke briefly with the Commander and scrambled back to join us, while another took his place.


By now, I’d been standing upright for twenty minutes, and my knees and lumbar throbbed. Without thinking, I leaned back against a boulder, and the other boys shifted in alarm.


Tzachi scowled disdainfully. “Stand straight!”


I now realized why everyone seemed so grim; standing motionless with all that weight was brutal. I hadn’t been in Koolé for more than an hour, and I was already in serious pain. “How long have you been standing here?” I whispered to the nearest boy, but Tzachi shot me another glance.


Ashamed, I remained mute for days.


After a while, Tzachi took me aside. He told me to begin walking across a field, scanning the terrain for imagined enemies. Then, he yelled, “Contact!” The correct response was to dive, roll, and scramble to the nearest boulder. Scan for a green cardboard target, estimate the distance with a closed eye and thumb, call out the yardage to imaginary colleagues, and rise, screaming “21, 22!”


By “23!”, I was to be back down, slithering to cover. When close enough, rise on one knee, throw a dummy grenade, and run, howling, “Forward Charge!” The correct procedure while charging was to drag your right leg to stabilize your body and shoot.


Once I’d passed the target, yell “Confirm Kill!” and scuttle back sideways, looking alternately forward and back. Then, place the muzzle of your gun against the cardboard figure’s head and double-tap: “Fire, Fire!”


After two practice runs, I was near-hysterical with pain. My elbows and knees were raw, my chest was heaving uncontrollably, and I’d torn my pants. None of the physical exercises I’d done over the previous year had prepared me for this - not the pushups, the jogging, or the pull-up bar stretched across the entrance to my tiny room. The Commander strolled over languidly. He couldn’t have been more than 25, but that day, he seemed like a deity. His voice remained a low whisper, but you could tell when he was angry; he grinned in a nasty, mocking kind of way.


Forty-one years later, I can still feel the fear. ---

James Ron is a retired social scientist. This piece originally appeared on his Substack. You can check out his academic work on ResearchGate or Google Scholar, or visit www.jamesron.com.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page